Caroline MCCarley —   leading with   COMMON sense for Brewster

Caroline McCarley has lived a lifetime of public service and leadership – and is making a difference in Brewster. She is running for Brewster Select Board on May 20th.

“Brewster is a special place, and I’m committed to protecting its future. With my decades of leadership and public service, I’ll work to safeguard our environment, strengthen our community, and ensure thoughtful planning for the challenges ahead. I ask for your support, and I look forward to working together for Brewster’s future.”
- Caroline McCarley

A Life of Service & Leadership

Caroline McCarley has dedicated her life to public service, guided by a deep commitment to community and common-sense leadership. With decades of experience in government, education, and civic engagement, she brings a wealth of knowledge and a collaborative approach to solving local challenges. Since moving to Brewster full-time in 2021, she has continued her tradition of service, actively contributing to key town initiatives and volunteer organizations. Whether leading committees, supporting local projects, or engaging with residents, Caroline is committed to strengthening Brewster’s future while preserving what makes it special.

brewster community service

  • Brewster Planning Board Member – Helping guide responsible town planning and development.
  • Chair, Sea Camps Advisory Committee – Leading discussions on the future use of this vital community asset.
  • Brewster Ladies Library Finance Committee & Volunteer – Supporting literacy, education, and financial oversight.
  • Bay Property Planning Committee Member (2022-2024) – Contributing to strategic land use planning.
  • Beautify Brewster Volunteer – Hands-on efforts to keep the town clean and welcoming
  • “Da Hedge” Coordinator – Organized food and beverages for Brewster community support during PanMass Challenge.

Roots in Family, Experience & Values

Caroline’s connection to Brewster extends 42 years. She and her family enjoyed summers at Linger Longer for many years. A lifelong advocate for community and public service, Caroline’s leadership is deeply shaped by her personal experiences. Born in Birmingham, Alabama, she built her career and raised her family in New Hampshire before making Brewster her home. Alongside her husband, Dan Harkinson, she has embraced both professional and volunteer roles that reflect her strong values of education, sustainability, and responsible governance. With three sons and three granddaughters, she understands the importance of making Brewster a thriving place for families of all generations. 

Personal Background:

  • Married for 50 years to Dan Harkinson, 2024 Brewster Conservation Trust Volunteer of the Year.
  • Mother of three sons and grandmother of three granddaughters.
  • Former Editorial Director at Wiley Publishing, bringing decades of experience in professional publishing.
  • Dedicated to education and civic engagement, from serving as a School Board Chair to mentoring future leaders.
  • Bachelor’s degree in economics from Davidson College.

Caroline’s leadership has always been guided by “Leading with Common Sense”—a philosophy that values practical decision-making, collaboration, and a deep respect for community voices.

CAROLINE'S PRIORITIES & Vision

LEADING WITH COMMON SENSE

01.

NATURAL ENVIRONMENT

Brewster’s open spaces, conservation lands, and coastal beauty define the town’s character and quality of life. Caroline is committed to preserving these resources by supporting responsible land use policies, protecting wildlife habitats, and ensuring that future development aligns with sustainability goals. She believes that maintaining Brewster’s natural beauty is essential not only for current residents but also for future generations who will call this community home.

02.

CLEAN AND SAFE WATER

Access to clean drinking water is a fundamental necessity, and Brewster has long been a leader in water quality management. Caroline is dedicated to continuing that legacy by advocating for policies that protect the town’s groundwater, ponds, and coastal waters. She will support infrastructure improvements, responsible wastewater management, and proactive measures to prevent contamination, ensuring that Brewster residents have safe, high-quality drinking water for years to come.

03.

HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES

Housing availability has become an increasing challenge in Brewster, making it difficult for young families, workers, and seniors to find affordable and suitable homes. Caroline supports initiatives that will increase attainable housing options while maintaining the unique character of Brewster. By promoting well-planned, thoughtful growth, she will work to ensure that residents have access to housing that meets their needs without compromising the town’s charm and natural beauty.

04.

SUSTAINABLE BUDGETS

Thoughtful financial management is critical to maintaining the quality of life in Brewster while ensuring that taxpayers are not overburdened. Brewster has produced award-winning municipal budgets. Caroline is committed to responsible budgeting that prioritizes essential town services, infrastructure improvements, and long-term financial stability. She will advocate for a transparent and efficient approach to town finances that ensures Brewster continues to thrive while maintaining fiscal responsibility.

05.

SEA CAMPS' FUTURE

The future of the Sea Camps properties is an issue of great importance to Brewster residents. Caroline believes that decisions regarding these properties must be made through a collaborative, transparent process that includes community input and careful financial planning. She is committed to ensuring that the town makes the most of these incredible assets by exploring solutions that align with Brewster’s needs and values, whether for recreation, conservation, or other community benefits.

06.

WITH COMMON SENSE

Brewster has built a reputation for good governance, strong leadership, and forward-thinking policies. Caroline is dedicated to continuing this tradition by advocating for policies that balance careful growth with preserving Brewster’s historic character. She believes in listening to residents, making data-driven decisions, and ensuring that Brewster remains a place where people want to live, work, and visit. By supporting strategic planning efforts, she will work to guide Brewster’s future in a way that honors its past while embracing opportunities for progress.

community support

endorsements

Amy Woods
I wholeheartedly support Caroline for Brewster Select Board. As a dedicated leader with deep town knowledge, she listens, builds consensus, and turns ideas into action. Her experience and commitment make her the right choice for Brewster’s future.
Dave Whitney
I highly support Caroline McCarley for the Brewster Select Board. Her leadership on the Sea Camps Advisory Committee, Planning Board, and Bay Property Planning Committee, along with her experience as a Mayor and State Senator, make her the right choice. Vote for Caroline on May 20th!
Cindy Bingham
I’m proud to endorse Caroline for Brewster Select Board. She quickly became a dedicated community leader, serving on the Planning Board and Sea Camps committees. With her leadership experience, she’ll be a strong advocate for Brewster. Vote for Caroline!
John Phillips
I’m a 17-year Brewster resident. I’ve worked with Caroline on the Bayside Property Planning Committee and admire her preparation, insight, and commitment. With experience as mayor and state senator, she’s a proven leader and consensus-builder. I strongly support Caroline.
Karl Fryzel
I’ve worked with Caroline on the Bay Property and Sea Camps committees and admire her fresh ideas, practical approach, and consensus-building skills. With her deep government experience and strong leadership, she’s the right choice for the Select Board.
Peter Johnson
Caroline McCarley is a proven leader with decades of public service, financial expertise, and a deep understanding of Brewster. She’ll be a great addition to the Select Board—vote for Caroline!
Sharon Tennstedt
Caroline’s dedication to public service and deep experience make her an exceptional candidate. I’ve worked with her on two committees and seen her impact firsthand. Brewster will greatly benefit from her leadership on the Select Board.
Clare O'connor-RICE
Caroline is a strong candidate for Brewster. A former NH mayor and active local leader, she listens, engages, and turns input into action. Her experience and balanced approach make her an excellent choice.
Jan Crocker
Caroline is my choice for Brewster Select Board. With 17 years on the Rochester, NH School Committee, plus experience as mayor and state senator, she brings the skills we need. I’ve served with her and admire her ability to listen and lead.
The Semples
We are thrilled Caroline is running for Select Board. With experience as a State Senator, Mayor, and School Board Chair, plus leadership on Brewster’s Planning Board, Sea Camps Advisory Committee, and Library Finance Committee, she is uniquely qualified. Caroline has the skills, energy, and vision to tackle Brewster’s biggest challenges. Vote for a fair and thoughtful future!
STRONG EXPERIENCE

More About
caroline mccarley

6 years

State Senator

Caroline served as a New Hampshire State Senator from 1997 to 2002, where she was a member of the Education, Finance, Fish & Game, and Health & Human Services Committees, advocating for responsible budgeting, strong schools, environmental conservation, and public health​.

5 years

mayor

Caroline served as Mayor of Rochester, New Hampshire, from 2016 to 2021, where she focused on downtown revitalization, responsible budgeting, and expanding community services while fostering collaboration and practical governance​.

2 years

governor's advisor

Caroline served as Senior Policy Advisor to New Hampshire Governor John Lynch from 2004 to 2005, providing strategic guidance on education, healthcare, and economic policy while ensuring practical, community-focused governance​.

17 years

school board chair & member

Caroline served on the Rochester School Board for 17 years (1988-2000, 2008-2012), including 11 years as Chair, where she led efforts to improve school facilities, expand educational opportunities, and ensure responsible budgeting for students and teachers​

BREWSTER SELECT BOARD

uPcoming Election DAY

00 00 00 00
brewster early voting info

Early voting will commence in Brewster starting in late April. 

Election day is May 20th 7am-8pm at Brewster Baptist Church.

If you have any questions please contact the Town Clerk’s Office, 508-896-4506.

we WANT YOU On CAROLINE'S Team

WHAT IS IMPORTANT TO YOU?

caroline Mccarley
leading with common sense

Brewster, Massachusetts
[email protected]
COUNTDOWN TO ELECTION DAY
00 00 00 00

Paid for by Friends of Caroline McCarley © All rights reserved 2025